Sawmill and kiln operator John Hurley
of JH Lumber Products scales and grades lumber for Middlebury College's
Bicentennial Hall. 1998.
Our History
“Conservation
means harmony between landowners and the land.
When land does well
for its owner, and the owner does well by the land;
when both end
up better by reason of their partnership, we have conservation. When
one or the other grows poorer, we do not.”
--From Aldo Leopold (1939) The Farmer as a Conservationist
Vermont’s Forested Landscape
Three hundred years ago
Vermont was blanketed by a healthy temperate rainforest. Within 150
years most of the forest had been cleared away and the land thoroughly
exploited. Today--due in large part to the land’s capacity
for self-renewal--forest now covers more than 78% of the state. In order
for this remarkable ecological recovery to continue we must learn
to manage our demands and to minimize adverse impacts.
Vermont expects a lot from her forests. These demands include timber
supplies, wood energy, non-timber forest products such as maple syrup,
and four seasons of recreation. Vermont also depends upon her forests
for high quality water supplies, pretty views, wildlife habitat, solitude,
and soul restoration. Many of these forest values are priceless for
the community yet valueless to the forest steward in the traditional
marketplace.
Vermont’s forests are adversely impacted by global warming,
air pollution and acid rain, invasive exotics, forest fragmentation
and simplification, and exploitive logging practices that result in
soil erosion, stream sedimentation, loss of biological diversity and
high-graded timber supplies. These adverse impacts are perpetuated
by an increasingly global economic system that always externalizes
costs and commonly fails to differentiate sources.
About 70% of Vermont’s forestland is non-industrial and privately
owned. Owners of these private forestlands often have diverse interests
and short tenure. Family forest owners often want to conserve the
health of their forests but do not know how to act upon their values.
Wendell Berry once wrote that the two great ruiners of private land
are ignorance and economic constraint. Vermont -- like many other
states -- has a long history of providing educational programs for
family-owned forest owners and the loggers and foresters who assist them.
These programs have focused more on forest products such as timber,
wildlife habitat, and recreation and less on forest health. Forest
health must receive greater attention. To paraphrase Vermont Smallholders
Association founder Justin Brand, “Without a healthy forest
ecology there cannot be a healthy forest economy.”
Vermont’s traditional forest industry model is a linear and
vertical one with forests and unempowered stewards at the bottom.
Vermont has focused much effort on attempting to improve timber quality
on family-owned forests but has expended little energy on systems that would
allow family-owned forest stewards to achieve greater success in forest
product marketing. Without this success in the marketplace, Vermont’s
family-owned forest owners and stewards cannot be expected to maintain the
health of their forests or to produce high quality forest products
over time.
These long-term emphases on forest products over forest health and
on high-quality timber production over the success of forest stewards
in the marketplace have put the ecological health and economic viability
of Vermont’s family-owned forests at considerable risk.
What VFF Has Accomplished
VFF puts healthy forests
first. VFF’s mission is “to conserve the health of the
forest community, and when appropriate to promote the careful cultivation
of local family-owned forests for community benefits.” Healthy forests
are fairly easy to spot. They are the ones that have clear, clean,
highly oxygenated streams running through them. They also have well
designed access networks that work with the land. Soils are stable
and productive, and there are diverse populations of native flora
and fauna.
Vermont Family Forests is a grassroots effort that started in 1995.
The Addison County Forester collaborated with the Lewis Creek Association
by offering workshops on many elements of careful forest stewardship.
After several of these very successful and well-attended workshops,
the collaborative educational effort was dubbed “Vermont Family
Forests.”
A mission, set
of principles, and a forest
management checklist were adopted and eleven workshops
were conducted on a wide variety of forest conservation subjects in
1996. In 1997, VFF identified 32 forest landowners -- with (continued
from page 1) about 5000 acres and an excellent history of stewardship
-- to form a pool of well-managed family-owned forests. VFF applied for
a grant through the Vermont Sustainable Jobs Fund to become certified
through the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC). VFF was certified by
FSC and incorporated as a non-profit corporation in 1998.

A broad-based dip stabilizes this access road on
a VFF certified forest.
VFF has established a small but well-equipped
office in Bristol and hired a part-time staff. VFF continues to offer
workshops related to ecologically sustainable forestry and has been
a leading sponsor in the Game of Logging training course. VFF also
provides ecological forestry information though its website,
newsletters,
annual reports, and other publications.
VFF has developed many systems and tools to support the family-owned forest
steward. VFF provides family-owned forest stewards with affordable access
to FSC certification. VFF
makes products
such as non-petroleum bar and chain oil, and publications,
such as log and tree scale and grade systems, management plan templates,
sample contracts, and forest health monitoring protocols readily available
to family-owned forest stewards.
VFF conducts research through
teams of natural resource managers, forest ecologists, community organizers,
ecological economists and other private contractors. Our most recently
completed project assessed the availability of sustainably harvested,
local, forest biomass as a fuel source for Middlebury College. The
report received high praise from Middlebury College.
VFF continues to work on the groundbreaking Community
Forests Project, which seeks to create conservation easements
that actually conserve the health of the forest while valuing the
forest so that landowners receive reasonable returns on their investments.
This is a critically important element, in that even if landowners
increase their success in the forest product marketplace exponentially,
the gap between the values of land as forest and developed land continue
to widen.
VFF has developed and tested a unique Community
Supported Forestry System that is circular, collaborative, and
local. In the VFF CSF System, forest products flow from healthy forests
through local value-adding processes and are then sold as branded
products to well-informed customers. More value is generated in the
local community and more value is returned to the forest and the stewards
of the forest. VFF experiments have identified substantial demand
for high quality forest products that originate from healthy local
forests and that result from collaborative local value adding.
-
Family forest stewards
often do not understand the basic principals of forest health or
the forest practices that conserve forest health.
-
Healthy forests where
ecologically sustainable forestry is practiced often generate lower
economic returns for the stewards in the short term.
-
Forest landowners have
infrequent harvests and these harvests often generate low volumes
and a variety of species that require aggregation and sorting to
improve economic value.
-
Family forest stewards
are not organized or positioned to convert low value logs into higher
value products and then to market those forest products successfully.
-
High quality value-adding
services such as sawmills, kilns, and commercial moulders for producing
hardwood trim and flooring are generally not available to family
forest owners under favorable circumstances.
-
Customers with aligned
values cannot easily access forest products from local forests that
have been independently certified as well managed.
-
The VFF certified pool
of well—managed forests is very limited in acreage and lacks
an economy of scale.
-
Forest landowners,
loggers, consulting foresters and other natural resource managers,
sawmill and kiln operators, and secondary wood product manufacturers
view each other as suppliers or even competitors rather than as
community members and stewardship partners.
-
Private consulting
foresters are often the primary source of information for family
forest owners, and can be financially conflicted between the roles
of forest manager and forest product broker.
-
The existing vertical
system provides participants at higher levels, particularly consulting
foresters and sawmills, with some success and strategic position,
and this can make them resistant to change.
-
Existing methods for
marketing standing timber and logs put family-owned forest owners at a
distinct disadvantage in that logs are scaled by, and the loggers
work for, the sawmills.
-
There is not a uniform
standard for log grade in Vermont.